Jump to content

hammb

MotownSports Fan
  • Posts

    1,026
  • Joined

  • Last visited

About hammb

  • Birthday 03/01/1980

Converted

  • Location
    Bowling Green, OH

Recent Profile Visitors

The recent visitors block is disabled and is not being shown to other users.

hammb's Achievements

MotownSports Fan

MotownSports Fan (1/1)

32

Reputation

  1. I didn't think there was a chance this team could get to double digit losses on the season. So I'll stand by my expectations of 50-60 wins. The sad truth is they have to IMPROVE to get to that point. The 2003 thing looks more likely.
  2. man that was vintage miggy. Sounded like a cannon
  3. I'm sure most all of us realize this, but I'm surprised it hasn't been mentioned here. Looking at those past draft classes, the first round picks that are highlighted as "hits", how many of them weren't even a great "scouting" job. I remember coveting JV because I read some stories about his prodigious arm, but after him, I seem to recall that most of those hits were based purely on Mike I's willingness to pay large signing bonuses that other teams wouldn't take on. Those years were before the draft salary limitations, so you could pay way over slot bonuses and not impact your ability to sign later draft picks (other than financially, obviously). I'm pretty sure that pure signability and willingness to buy kids out of their college commitments was the only real reason we drafted guys like Maybin, Miller, Porcello, and Castellanos. I think based on pure talent, all of them went much later in the draft than they should have...sort of "making it easy" to pick the right guys. Even then I think it's pretty fair to say all 4 of those guys never reached the potential they were thought to have as players. Sure, that stuff happens to prospects everywhere, and kids that come in with fanfare are more likely to disappoint than they are to overly impress, still I think it brings some questioning to our development that we were able to take ultra premium talent and still not turn them into perennial all stars. JV & Granderson are the only 2 legit stars that we've drafted & developed over the past 20 years or so. I'm sure there are other orgs that have been equally futile, but man it's painful. And of course when it's a development issue at hand (which I firmly believe it is), we've also not even really lucked into any All Stars either. Thankfully DD was mostly great at turning prospects into ML All Stars, and even finding and fixing some diamond in the rough ML players like JD. This team has never done good enough developing players to build a competent MLB roster from its own talent. And now that's what we're trying to do almost like we think bringing in outside players would cheapen it if we actually found a way to not lose 100 games.
  4. MOST of those guys haven't tasted an ounce of success above AA ball. Several are already nearing washout status since they really haven't had much success even in AAA. The ones that have made it to the big leagues only Candelario, and MAYBE Castro, have shown they have futures as actual major league contributors. I suppose you could count a couple of the relievers as well, but they're ultra small samples, and relief pitching is volatile anyhow. The handful of supposed gem prospects that have actually made it to the show (Paredes, Mize, and Skubal) have all struggled pretty mightily. Not writing them off of course, but for guys ranked in the top 100 prospects it'd be nice to see one of them come up and actually play WELL to start their career before we're penciling them in as the foundation of the next WS team.
  5. I wish I could say I was surprised by how this thing is starting, but it's exactly what I expected. Illitch is a fool who refuses to fund even attempting to win baseball games. Avila is completely over his head and has shown nothing worth looking forward to. He gave away the greatest pitcher in Tigers history for zero reason other than cutting payroll. None of the prospects returned for that trade look like they'll make it to the bigs and contribute anything. **** I wouldn't be shocked if the combined return on that trade produces less career WAR for the Tigers than what JV did just the rest of that 2017 season for Houston. Let alone going on to win another Cy Young, another No-no, etc. I have zero faith in this thing actually working, and I won't until they show they can develop any of the players that they drafted. I won't believe it has a chance to work until they actually show the ability to figure out which established MLB players could come in here and help us win, and then ACTUALLY SIGN THEM. I think this could be a fun season to watch the Hens, hopefully we get to see some of the prospects play here, but I have to say I'm not that enamored with most of our prospects either. Seems like we have a bunch of guys who are/were highly rated as prospects, but they all seem to eventually hit a wall somewhere and stall in development. I hope like **** that changes, but man it's tough to give a **** about a team that is run by people who appear to also not give a ****.
  6. No doubt there was a lot of luck involved with Pudge & Maggs both working out with their injury history. And the landscape has changed so much for the big time FAs as well in the last 15 years I'm not even sure if what I want is still feasible. I'm not asking for superstars. I just think we need to start signing SOMEBODY in FA that you think can actually contribute to a competitive (if not contending) team. Personally, I would NEVER sign a Lindor type deal unless it's to retain a HoF homegrown player. I had no issues with JV and Miggy's contracts because I wanted to see those guys around forever, even if it did hamper our ability to win down the line. I would never go out into FA looking at those top tier FAs wanting 8+ year deals. But I do think at some point we have to go out and add legit talent. Ozuna, for instance, was signed this year to a sub $20m salary and not commited past his age 35 season. Maybe we have to tack on a "we suck" premium to his salary or add a year, but at some point we simply must add some legit talent. Ever since we traded away JV (which was completely asinine) this team has been tanking like **** in the hopes they can win like the Indians/Astros with nothing but cheap talent. That's absurd, and I don't think our FO is a fraction as good as those front offices are/were.
  7. To me now is as good a time as any to start adding SOME FA vets. Unless you think that the current crop of prospects is STILL 3+ years out from making it to the big leagues. I always look back at our last successful rebuild. We didn't go out and add Pudge, Magglio, Polanco, Guillen, and Rogers all in one offseason. We brought in that talent over the preceding 2-3 years to have some worthwhile vets ready when the better prospects in our system were ready to come up. I don't think it makes great sense to sign zero worthwhile FAs until your young players are up and established. You're not going to bring in a bunch of contributors in one offseason. IF you wait to add vets until after your supposed "young core" is ready, by the time you add enough vets to round out your team that young core has likely gotten expensive.
  8. Is it worth mentioning that another major difference was that in 2003 tickets were far cheaper? Perhaps more specifically the Tigers back then were donating a ton of tickets to local promotions so you could "win" tickets through radio promos, etc. To purchase I think you could routinely get bleacher seats for under $10. As a result I know I attended 4 games that year (somehow seeing 4 wins in that disaster of a season). This year everytime I log in to think about buying tickets I'm just disgusted by the price and exit out. I know they ran some "flash sales" or something, but I missed out on the right time to order tickets when they were still cheap. I see they're running some $15 promos this weekend (when I cannot make it), so I guess they're finally starting to rectify this. Just going onto the site to order tickets (without making sure you're on the right promo day or flash sale) bleacher seats are retail at like $34 each, before their fees. That becomes close to $45. For outfield bleacher seats. To watch a team that will lose 105+ games.
  9. Sure was a blast to watch. And I can watch the likes of Vlad Jr. take BP all night long. It's a spectacle of power. I enjoyed last night's festivities far more than any Tigers game for several years now.
  10. That will forever be the trade by which I judge Avila. And by that I mean to say I'm not sure there is ANYTHING the players returned could possibly do to make me look at it favorably. JV was the only reason I was still watching games, he was still pitching as well as anybody in baseball, and he was still under team control for several more seasons. Yes, he made a high salary, but he was earning it on the field. In my opinion JV should have never even been thought of as a tradable piece for any price, period. My son wasn't old enough to know anything about Verlander, but I will never forget the first game I watched with him, the day we came home from the hospital. JV took a no-no into the 9th against the Angels. If you wanted to make it purely about "value" and detach all emotion from the issue (which I refuse to do) JV has, in his remaining Tiger controlled years, amassed 11.8 WAR for Houston. I'm not convinced we'll see 11.8 WAR from all the players we got in return combined. And since I cannot detach emotion, I"ll continue to reiterate players of JV (and Miggy) caliber should be paid until the day they decide to retire. I don't care if we're watching a broken down shell of the version we remember, there is value (IMO) to watching HoF guys play out the string of their career for my team. ****, he's not even close to an elite hitter anymore but Miggy is still about the only time I perk up to pay attention to this team anymore.
  11. I don't disagree with you at all, but I also don't think you can just wait until you're "ready to contend" to START that buying. You're not going to go out and buy 3-4 impact bats in one offseason. Look at our last successful rebuild. We signed Pudge in '04, we signed Magglio in '05. We didn't really start to see returns on those things until '06 when we added Rogers and brought JV & Zumaya up, but we had all star caliber MLB bats already on the team. We also traded for Guillen in '04 and Polanco in '05. Had they not started adding those FA bats 2 years before the "window" I don't know that the "window" would have been nearly as successful. That '06 offense was mostly reliant on established MLB talent that was not developed/drafted by Detroit, but we didn't wait for all of our prospects to hit MLB before we started adding them.
  12. Firstly, never said that I won't be rooting for them. Certainly I will. I have no problem watching a young, obviously talented team, grow. **** it's a lot of fun. But what I predict for the next year or two is something a lot more akin to 2003 where we're filling a roster with a bunch of AAAA fodder, because we're still several years from any REAL prospects making their debuts. And that is not entertaining to me in the least. I can deal with it in Football, watch horrible teams looking for the one or two young brightspots...but not baseball. Not a sport that plays 162 games over 6 months time. During the best weather time of year when there are countless other things to do. This has the makings of returning baseball to the Phil Garner days where I pay attention for the start of APril then forget baseball is even being played by mid-May. If you can find entertainment value in watching a 100 loss team in the hopes of seeing the early years of the next Bobby Higginson, more power to ya...I cannot. If that makes me a bandwagoner so be it, but it is what it is. 162 games of crap baseball is NOT my idea of quality summertime entertainment. Keeping JV on the team guaranteed at least 30 of those games had entertainment value.
  13. See that's just it. I don't think it IS necessary. Does it maybe make us a better team in 3 years than we would be if we just let JV stick around? Sure, it probably does. But I don't think it's necessary either. Draft well, develop the talent. I find it impossible to believe that picking up these 3 prospects was the difference in the 2020 team winning or not winning. Again, it's not that I have a problem with the business aspect. I had no problems moving Price, Upton, Cespedes, etc. I get the business aspect of the game. I disagree that the business aspect or winning is always the primary concern for me, as a fan. JV is not just another player. He is the best player the Tigers have drafted in my lifetime. He is the best pitcher the Tigers have had in my lifetime. I expect those statements to remain true for a VERY long time. Watching him pitch has more value to me than a few wins in 2020, and I think a well run organization could build a future winner while still letting me watch him pitch in the meantime.
  14. Thing is with Max I had seen him already pitch at the MLB level. I saw his stuff make MLB hitters look stupid. Yeah, he had had some ups and downs and was far from established, but I (and I'm sure others) not only knew who he was, but had seen him pitch. And even though Granderson was my favorite player at the time (and first jersey I ever purchased), he wasn't nearly on JV's level. JV is a HoF talent, and the guys we got back are not even ready to help Toledo win yet.
  15. Sure 3 years from now, IF they are actually winning again, I'll be happy for the current state of the team. But I don't watch the Tigers only for wins. I watch for entertainment. Winning is part of that, of course, but I've still made it a point to follow the team on JV days all season despite how awful we are. So yeah, 3 years from now if this trade pans out, I'll have some entertainment to look forward to. In the meantime I doubt that I'll even give a second thought to opening day, let alone the rest of the season for the '18/19 seasons. And the rest of '17 is garbage is well. This trade has essentially ended baseball for me for the next 3 years. At least we still have Miggy, I guess
×
×
  • Create New...