What Will Become of Nicholas Castellanos?

[Lei Pong 155]

If he could play OF at an acceptable level and hit like he did last year...he'd be a perennial all star quality player worthy of a 20 million contract at minimum.  But...neither of those things are true so...Ithrow up my hands, Nick.  WTH is Avila supposed to do with a DH with a 750ish OPS?

[LooseGoose 679]

19 minutes ago, Lei Pong said:

If he could play OF at an acceptable level and hit like he did last year...he'd be a perennial all star quality player worthy of a 20 million contract at minimum.  But...neither of those things are true so...Ithrow up my hands, Nick.  WTH is Avila supposed to do with a DH with a 750ish OPS?

Trade him for 2 Top 10 level prospects or be fired for incompetence.

[Motor City Sonics 899]

 A lot of this comes down to Al Avila opening his stupid mouth and saying nobody wanted to trade for him. 

 

As Brutal said to Delacroix in The Green Mile   "Learn when to shut up"

I like when GMs actually answer questions, as long as they are the right ones to answer.   Al has failed on this big time on a few occasions.   

[chasfh 1,258]

Have the Ilitches ever fired anyone for incompetence?

[LooseGoose 679]

14 minutes ago, chasfh said:

Have the Ilitches ever fired anyone for incompetence?

8/4/15

[chasfh 1,258]

3 minutes ago, LooseGoose said:

8/4/15

Perhaps that was due more to palace intrigue than incompetence?

[Shelton 1,371]

11 minutes ago, chasfh said:

Perhaps that was due more to palace intrigue than incompetence?

Perhaps. At the same time, DD did an objectively poor job building the 2014 and 2015 teams resulting in the 2015 deadline sell-off. I think you could view that as being fired for incompetence. 

 

[chasfh 1,258]

21 minutes ago, Shelton said:

Perhaps. At the same time, DD did an objectively poor job building the 2014 and 2015 teams resulting in the 2015 deadline sell-off. I think you could view that as being fired for incompetence. 

 

You might, although the same regime who were on the same basic philosophical page simply all moved up one slot on the chart.

[Oblong 2,156]

I don't think it was incompetence with DD.   

 

[chasfh 1,258]

I have my doubts about that as well. Someone at the top who's fired for incompetence is usually followed by the ouster of several of his top lieutenants and replaced with a new regime bringing in a new way of doing things.

Considering that, I wish DD had been fired for incompetence. 

[Oblong 2,156]

15 minutes ago, chasfh said:

I have my doubts about that as well. Someone at the top who's fired for incompetence is usually followed by the ouster of several of his top lieutenants and replaced with a new regime bringing in a new way of doing things.

Considering that, I wish DD had been fired for incompetence. 

With Ilitch's failing health and the family knowing what was coming there isn't any room for a personality like DD.  The family had no involvement with the Tigers and DD would have overshadowed Chris or anyone else... can't have that.

[Keepleyland2 760]

23 hours ago, Tenacious D said:

Those polls required way too much thought.

And were confusing

How many hanging Chad's are there? Do we need to get the supreme court invovled?

[Lei Pong 155]

I know Chadd isn't the best scouting director.... or whatever he is...but hanging him is a but much.

[Shelton 1,371]

43 minutes ago, chasfh said:

You might, although the same regime who were on the same basic philosophical page simply all moved up one slot on the chart.

Yes, that’s true, but the current level of incompetence doesn’t excuse the incompetence of their former leader. 

[chasfh 1,258]

4 minutes ago, Shelton said:

Yes, that’s true, but the current level of incompetence doesn’t excuse the incompetence of their former leader. 

True as well, but if the reason for the firing truly was incompetence, then shouldn't all the other incompetent leadership been shown the door as well?

[Mr. Bigglesworth 3,207]

2 hours ago, Motor City Sonics said:

 A lot of this comes down to Al Avila opening his stupid mouth and saying nobody wanted to trade for him.

Literally none of this comes down to that.

[Mr. Bigglesworth 3,207]

The front office's PR was too glowing when Nick was a prospect and not glowing enough now that he is a Tiger.

[Shelton 1,371]

34 minutes ago, chasfh said:

True as well, but if the reason for the firing truly was incompetence, then shouldn't all the other incompetent leadership been shown the door as well?

Maybe. Maybe not. 

 

[Oblong 2,156]

perhaps

[chasfh 1,258]

if the remaining incompetent leadership was left in place, that suggests that incompetence probably wasn't the issue.

[Shelton 1,371]

20 minutes ago, chasfh said:

if the remaining incompetent leadership was left in place, that suggests that incompetence probably wasn't the issue.

Wonderful. That means we are in good hands. 

[chasfh 1,258]

It’s why I’m rooting for a sale of the team. 

[Lei Pong 155]

Yeah...maybe Tom Gores will buy the team.  He's been a wonderful owner for the Pistons.  

 

NOT!!!

 

Man...I sure love old timey internet cliches

[leflore 56]

Dan Gilbert was released from the hospital today for the stroke he suffered a few weeks ago. I had hoped the Illitch family would sell the Tigers to him and it was interesting that Gilbert was severing ties with casinos. Gilbert can appear to be somewhat of a nutjob but he is very invested in Detroit, passionate about sports and the city and has been willing to spend huge with the Cavs. I hope he is mending well and I'd still like to see the Illitch's sell him the Tigers

[LooseGoose 679]

3 hours ago, chasfh said:

True as well, but if the reason for the firing truly was incompetence, then shouldn't all the other incompetent leadership been shown the door as well?

If the leader was incompetent the rest of the team might have been very competent yet simply overruled.