Page 1 of 3 123 LastLast
Results 1 to 40 of 85

Thread: My Mock Draft

  1. #1
    Stormin' Norman's Avatar
    Stormin' Norman is online now MotownSports Fan
    Join Date
    Jan 2009
    Location
    Orlando, FL
    Posts
    1,390

    Default My Mock Draft




    My Two Round Mock Draft:

    1. Detroit Lions – Matt Stafford QB Georgia
    I firmly believe in Matt Stafford and I think his stock will only go up from here. He is receiving glowing reviews of his interview skills and he showed he had some speed with a 4.84 40 at the combine. The Lions need Mathew Stafford, this could be the best pick in franchise history.

    2. St. Louis Rams – Aaron Curry LB Wake Forrest
    Aaron Curry had an amazing combine and he is a player that can play any position asked of him. He has the size to play in the middle, he has the speed to play outside he has the cover ability to play nickel and he has the strength to play with his hand on the ground. Spagnola starting his team with Curry could be a perfect fit.

    3. Kansas City Chiefs – Brian Cushing ILB USC
    Brian Cushing’s stock has been going only up since the Rose Bowl and I think he could find himself in the top 3. KC wants Aaron Curry but they still need help at linebacker regardless. I think Cushing and Johnson could make for a great linebacker tandem.

    4. Seattle Seahawks – Michael Crabtree WR Texas Tech
    Michael Crabtree had a horrible combine but I don’t think he falls past Seattle still. He should perform adequately on his pro day and he has the most impressive film of any player in this draft. He is a lock here.

    5. Cleveland Browns – Brian Orakpo OLB Texas
    Brian Orakpo is a workout warrior and he could be exactly what Mangini thought Vernon Gholston was last year. He is a true pass rusher who should be a great replacement for either Andre Davis or Willie McGinest.

    6. Cincinnati Bengals – Jason Smith OT Baylor
    Jason Smith has cemented his spot as the best tackle in the draft and Cincinnati will be counting their blessings if he falls to this spot. This fills Cincinnati’s most crucial with this pick.

    7. Oakland Raiders – Darrius Heyward-Bey WR Maryland
    Al Davis loves speed and so that means this year he loves Darrius Heyward-Bey. He is taller and faster than Maclin and Al Davis would love to see McFadden throwing long to DHB.

    8. Jacksonville Jaguars – Eugene Monroe OT
    Jacksonville’s offensive line woes last year destroyed their chances to be a contender last year. Eugene Monroe is a fantastic tackle prospect and he will start for the Jaguars on Day 1.

    9. Green Bay Packers – Everette Brown OLB Florida State
    Everette Brown played defensive line in college, but is being seen as a 3-4 OLB. Green Bay needs players to fit their change to the system and Brown fits that profile.

    10. San Francisco 49ers – Larry English OLB Northern Illinois
    Larry English has soared up draft boards and continues to impress. He looked fantastic at the combine and Michael Singletary will have a great partner to Patrick Willis.

    11. Buffalo Bills – Tyson Jackson DE LSU
    The Bills had no pressure on the passer last year, Tyson Jackson is a big physical defensive end that should help them fix that problem.

    12. Denver Broncos – B.J. Raji NT Boston College
    B.J. Raji is arguably one of the top two defensive prospects in the draft and he would be a Godsend to Denver. He has the ability to dominate and would serve as a perfect nose guard in Nolan’s 34 defense.

    13. Washington Redskins – Andre Smith OT Alabama
    Andre Smith could have been the number one pick in the draft, but falling to Washington could be the best for both parties. Andre could start as a right tackle in 2009 and though I question his ability to play on the left side he should be a very good right tackle or guard with the skills demonstrated at Alabama.

    14. New Orleans Saints – Malcom Jenkins CB Ohio State
    The Saints have needs at both Safety and Cornerback so Malcom Jenkins is a perfect fit here. People are split on which position he should be, but either way he should improve New Orleans’s poor secondary.

    15. Houston Texans – Robert Ayers DE/OLB Tennessee
    Robert Ayers is another late bloomer. He only had one great year at Tennessee, but he has performed well at the Senior Bowl and the combine. He could give Mario Williams a pass rush presence on the other side.

    16. San Diego Chargers – Chris “Beanie” Wells RB Ohio State
    Since LT’s days seem to be numbered in San Diego, Beanie Wells could prove to be a great thunder and lightning combo with Darren Sproles.

    17. New York Jets – Knowshon Moreno RB Georgia
    Thomas Jones is turning 30 and New York is going to need a running attack with the passing attack suffering from the loss of Brett Favre. Knowshon could be an NFL star and his personality would make him beloved by the New York media.

    18. Chicago Bears – Kenny Britt WR Rutgers
    Kenny Britt is a good looking prospect at 6’4 with great speed he has been climbing up draft boards. He should give Chicago a legitimate weapon to play opposite Devin Hester.

    19. Tampa Bay Buccaneers – Mark Sanchez QB USC
    This could be an ideal situation for Mark Sanchez who has great tools, but I feel will struggle if played too early. It seems that Luke McCown has worked his way to starting QB for 2009, but I don’t think anyone expects him to be the future of the franchise.

    20. Detroit Lions –Aaron Maybin OLB Penn State
    I expect Detroit to pick up a MLB in the free agency, and Ernie Sims is a great linebacker and this pick should finish the job. I think Detroit can address cornerback late in the draft and Max Unger should still be available come pick 33.

    21. Philadelphia Eagles – Brandon Pettigrew TE Oklahoma State
    Pettigrew is a great tight end prospect that can both block and catch. Pettigrew will help support an aging offensive line and fills a need with the departure of LJ Smith.

    22. Minnesota Vikings – Vontae Davis CB Illinois
    With Minnesota trading for Sage Rosenfils I don’t think Minnesota will take a huge gamble on Josh Freeman. Minnesota needs help in the aging defensive backfield and Vontae Davis can provide it.

    23. New England Patriots – Clay Mathews LB USC
    Clay Mathews is a solid football player from a great family. He can play any position the Patriots ask of him and he fits the profile of a Patriots linebacker.

    24. Atlanta Falcons – D.J. Moore CB Vanderbilt
    D.J. Moore was absolutely amazing as both a cornerback and a kick returner and the Falcons need help at both. They would love Brandon Pettigrew here.

    25. Miami Dolphins - James Laurinaitis ILB Ohio State
    James Laurinatitis isn’t the sexiest prospect in the draft, but the guy is a football player and I could see Parcells falling in love with him.

    26. Baltimore Ravens - Alphonso Smith CB Wake Forrest
    Baltimore’s weakness in their D was the long passing game and Alphonso Smith is a good step towards repairing that. The guy doesn’t have the best measurable but no CB has performed better in college.

    27. Indianapolis Colts – Percy Harvin WR Florida
    Harrison is gone and the Colts have the ability to simply reload. Harvin could provide lethal speed and should add an exciting new spark to Peyton’s offense. The Colts have a real need at DT, but I don’t think any prospect warrants this pick.

    28. Philadelphia Eagles - Michael Oher OT Mississippi
    Some once had Michael Oher as the top tackle in the draft, he has now fallen to the late first round. Philadelphia’s offensive tackles both have more than 10 years of experience and its time to build towards the future.

    29. New York Giants - Brian Robiskie WR Ohio State
    Brian Robiskie gave one of the most impressive combine performances and has pushed his way into the first round. This is New York’s number one need, even if Plaxico escapes jail time.

    30. Tennessee Titans – Jarron Gilbert DT San Jose State
    Jarron Gilbert has become a youtube sensation and is a physical freak. His measurables are ridiculous for a defensive tackle and he could be asked to fill Albert Haynesworth’s rather large shoes.

    31. Arizona Cardinals – Donald Brown RB Connecticut
    Donald Brown had a better combine performance than either of the two RB’s I have in front of him and he should provide a good alternative to Tim Hightower.

    32. Pittsburgh Steelers – William Beatty OT Conneticut
    Marvel Smith has yet to be signed and William Beatty is the best tackle available.

    Round 2.

    1. Detroit Lions – Max Unger C Oregon
    Max Unger could be the best offensive line prospect for the Lions in this draft. He can play center, guard or right tackle and he will start day one.

    2. St. Louis Rams - Eben Britton OT Arizona
    Many expect St. Louis to pick a tackle in the first round, so its obvious the need is there. Eben Britton has risen since the end of the season.

    3. Kansas City Chiefs - Paul Kruger DE Utah
    That Kansas City defense needs a lot of help and Paul Kruger could provide a great spark.

    4. Cleveland Browns - Coye Francies CB San Jose State
    Coye Francies came from a small school but has seen his stock risen thanks to a fantastic Senior Bowl practice.

    5. Seattle Seahawks – Peria Jerry DT Mississippi
    Seattle needs help on both lines, but there isn’t a tackle here worth the pick.

    6. Cincinnati Bengals – C Alex Mack
    Alex Mack coupled with Jason Smith is a great way to build a long lasting offensive line.

    7. Jacksonville Jaguars – Hakeem Nicks WR North Carolina
    Jacksonville has made some head scratching moves trying to solve the wide receiver position, lets hope they can fill it here.

    8. Oakland Raiders – Sean Smith CB Utah
    Sean Smith is a very interesting CB prospect at 6’4.

    9. Green Bay Packers -- Darius Butler CB Connecticut
    Their defensive backfield is aging.

    10. Buffalo Bills – Jared Cook TE South Carolina
    Jared Cook is a physical freak and could be a real sexy receiving option for Trent Edwards.

    11. San Francisco 49ers – Josh Freeman QB Kansas State
    Josh Freeman is arguably a first round talent, San Francisco can’t rely on Shaun Hill or Alex Smith being the QB of the future.

    12. Miami Dolphins – Louis Delmas S Western Michigan
    Thanks to William Moore’s poor performance at the Senior Bowl Louis Delmas becomes the top prospect.

    13. New Orleans Saints -- Rey Maualuga OLB USC
    He had a poor combine and some question his speed so he may fall out of the first round.

    14. New York Giants -- Tyrone McKenzie OLB USF
    He’s a big, strong OLB prospect that New York needs.

    15. Houston Texans -- Michael Johnson DE Georgia Tech
    Michael Johnson is a statistical beast with all the talent in the world, but was an inconsistent performer. If Mario Williams can help him fulfill his potential he could provide a scary alternative.

    16. New England Patriots -- Rashad Johnson S Alabama
    Rodney Harrison is on the NFL Network.

    17. Denver Broncos -- Marcus Freeman LB Ohio State
    Denver needs linebackers and Marcus Freeman has high upside.

    18. Chicago Bears -- Andy Levitre OG Oregon State
    The best guard in the draft in a weak year for the position.

    19. Tampa Bay Buccaneers -- Connor Barwin DE Cincinnati
    Kevin Carter is getting old and they need to look for a replacement.

    20. Dallas Cowboys William Moore S Missouri
    Was once the top safety in the draft, but he should be able to replace Roy Williams.

    21. Philadelphia Eagles LeSean McCoy RB Pittsburgh
    Philadelphia needs a between the tackles runner, LeSean McCoy could be that back.

    22. New York Jets –Jairus Byrd CB Oregon
    The Jet’s secondary is pathetic and they need help at the position.

    23. Minnesota Vikings -- Jamon Meredith OT South Carolina
    Jamon Meredith has all the physical tools but got benched in college. He has huge potential but has bust written all over him.

    24. Atlanta Falcons -- Shawn Nelson TE Southern Mississippi
    I was more impressed with Nelson than any other receiver at the combine.

    25. Miami Dolphins -- Juaquin Iglesias WR Oklahoma
    Miami needs more fire power at wide receiver.

    26. Baltimore Ravens -- Cornelius Ingram TE Florida
    Ingram was hurt last year but looked solid at the combine. Baltimore needs to make up for Todd Heap’s slowing in production.

    27. New England Patriots – Herman Johnson OG/OT LSU
    A huge prospect that can play either guard or tackle.

    28. Carolina Panthers -- Nate Davis QB Carolina
    The NFC Championship game made it obvious Carolina needs to prepare for a day without Jake Delhomme.

    29. New York Giants Evander Hood DT Missouri
    Evander Hood was one of the strongest defensive lineman in the draft.

    30. Indianapolis Colts – Ron Bryce DT Boston College
    He played behind Raji, but he is a talented player that the Colts desperately need.

    31. Tennessee Titans – Pat White QB West Virginia
    Pat White looked great the combine and offers a lot of possibility in Tennessee. The Titans need another receiver, help at punt return and with Vince Young being Vince Young he may have a shot at playing Quarterback.

    32. Arizona Cardinals -- Duke Robinson OG Oklahoma
    This would be a high value pick here.

    Pittsburgh Steelers -- Jonathan Luigs C Louisville
    An athletic center prospect that can help keep Big Ben upright.

  2. #2
    itsallgood8989's Avatar
    itsallgood8989 is offline MotownSports Fan
    Join Date
    Oct 2005
    Location
    Here and there!
    Posts
    1,391

    Default

    Nice job! Don't agree with all of them, but that is to be expected!
    2012 ATT Hernan Perez
    2011 ATT Kevin Eichorn
    2009 ATTAnthony Shawler 2010 ATT Miguel Cabrera

  3. #3
    Dirk Diggler is offline MotownSports Fan
    Join Date
    Jun 2007
    Location
    lakeland
    Posts
    2,642

    Default

    Looks good....now I wanna see 3-7.
    Adopt-a-Tiger: 08' Lucas French, 09' Andrew Oliver 1-0 vs NCAA, 10' Daniel Fields

    Adopt-a-Lion: 08' Dan Orlovsky, 09' Jeff Backus

  4. #4
    SuperFlew's Avatar
    SuperFlew is offline MotownSports Fan
    Join Date
    Nov 2007
    Location
    Saginaw, MI
    Posts
    288

    Default

    Has Jeremy Maclin really fallen out of the first two rounds?
    "A little slap 'n pickle. I'm drunk, you're drunk, everybody's drunk!" - Barry Badrinath

  5. #5
    EatEmUpTigers711's Avatar
    EatEmUpTigers711 is offline MotownSports Fan
    Join Date
    May 2007
    Location
    Harper Woods
    Posts
    8,673

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by SuperFlew View Post
    Has Jeremy Maclin really fallen out of the first two rounds?
    I don't think so.....I still think Crabtree, Maclin & Heyward-Bey are the top 3 WR's coming out, and I really wouldn't expect Iglesias to go before Maclin, or Heyward-Bey for sure, and maybe not even before Britt, Robiskie, Nicks or Harvin.
    2012 Adopt-A-Tiger - Ryan Strieby
    2011 Adopt-A-Lion - #26 Louis Delmas - 51 Tackles

  6. #6
    Hongbit's Avatar
    Hongbit is offline MotownSports Fan
    Join Date
    Apr 2002
    Location
    Out There
    Posts
    12,102

    Default

    I give you an A for the effort. A full 2 round mock with analysis is a hard thing to do even if I disagree with many of your selections.

    I honestly would throw a rock at my TV if the Lions took a Center at the top of the 2nd round with so many quality playmakers still on the board. Taking Unger over Maclin, Jerry, Nicks, and yes even Maualuga would be reaching for need rather taking the best available player. Eric Wood, Antoine Caldwell, and AQ Shipley are available later and round out a center class with nice depth.
    VT

  7. #7
    Stormin' Norman's Avatar
    Stormin' Norman is online now MotownSports Fan
    Join Date
    Jan 2009
    Location
    Orlando, FL
    Posts
    1,390

    Default

    Can't believe I overlooked Maclin.

    1. Detroit Lions – Matt Stafford QB Georgia
    I firmly believe in Matt Stafford and I think his stock will only go up from here. He is receiving glowing reviews of his interview skills and he showed he had some speed with a 4.84 40 at the combine. The Lions need Mathew Stafford, this could be the best pick in franchise history.

    2. St. Louis Rams – Aaron Curry LB Wake Forrest
    Aaron Curry had an amazing combine and he is a player that can play any position asked of him. He has the size to play in the middle, he has the speed to play outside he has the cover ability to play nickel and he has the strength to play with his hand on the ground. Spagnola starting his team with Curry could be a perfect fit.

    3. Kansas City Chiefs – Brian Cushing ILB USC
    Brian Cushing’s stock has been going only up since the Rose Bowl and I think he could find himself in the top 3. KC wants Aaron Curry but they still need help at linebacker regardless. I think Cushing and Johnson could make for a great linebacker tandem.

    4. Seattle Seahawks – Michael Crabtree WR Texas Tech
    Michael Crabtree had a horrible combine but I don’t think he falls past Seattle still. He should perform adequately on his pro day and he has the most impressive film of any player in this draft. He is a lock here.

    5. Cleveland Browns – Brian Orakpo OLB Texas
    Brian Orakpo is a workout warrior and he could be exactly what Mangini thought Vernon Gholston was last year. He is a true pass rusher who should be a great replacement for either Andre Davis or Willie McGinest.

    6. Cincinnati Bengals – Jason Smith OT Baylor
    Jason Smith has cemented his spot as the best tackle in the draft and Cincinnati will be counting their blessings if he falls to this spot. This fills Cincinnati’s most crucial with this pick.

    7. Oakland Raiders – Darrius Heyward-Bey WR Maryland
    Al Davis loves speed and so that means this year he loves Darrius Heyward-Bey. He is taller and faster than Maclin and Al Davis would love to see McFadden throwing long to DHB.

    8. Jacksonville Jaguars – Eugene Monroe OT
    Jacksonville’s offensive line woes last year destroyed their chances to be a contender last year. Eugene Monroe is a fantastic tackle prospect and he will start for the Jaguars on Day 1.

    9. Green Bay Packers – Everette Brown OLB Florida State
    Everette Brown played defensive line in college, but is being seen as a 3-4 OLB. Green Bay needs players to fit their change to the system and Brown fits that profile.

    10. San Francisco 49ers – Larry English OLB Northern Illinois
    Larry English has soared up draft boards and continues to impress. He looked fantastic at the combine and Michael Singletary will have a great partner to Patrick Willis.

    11. Buffalo Bills – Tyson Jackson DE LSU
    The Bills had no pressure on the passer last year, Tyson Jackson is a big physical defensive end that should help them fix that problem.

    12. Denver Broncos – B.J. Raji NT Boston College
    B.J. Raji is arguably one of the top two defensive prospects in the draft and he would be a Godsend to Denver. He has the ability to dominate and would serve as a perfect nose guard in Nolan’s 34 defense.

    13. Washington Redskins – Andre Smith OT Alabama
    Andre Smith could have been the number one pick in the draft, but falling to Washington could be the best for both parties. Andre could start as a right tackle in 2009 and though I question his ability to play on the left side he should be a very good right tackle or guard with the skills demonstrated at Alabama.

    14. New Orleans Saints – Malcom Jenkins CB Ohio State
    The Saints have needs at both Safety and Cornerback so Malcom Jenkins is a perfect fit here. People are split on which position he should be, but either way he should improve New Orleans’s poor secondary.

    15. Houston Texans – Robert Ayers DE/OLB Tennessee
    Robert Ayers is another late bloomer. He only had one great year at Tennessee, but he has performed well at the Senior Bowl and the combine. He could give Mario Williams a pass rush presence on the other side.

    16. San Diego Chargers – Chris “Beanie” Wells RB Ohio State
    Since LT’s days seem to be numbered in San Diego, Beanie Wells could prove to be a great thunder and lightning combo with Darren Sproles.

    17. New York Jets – Knowshon Moreno RB Georgia
    Thomas Jones is turning 30 and New York is going to need a running attack with the passing attack suffering from the loss of Brett Favre. Knowshon could be an NFL star and his personality would make him beloved by the New York media.

    18. Chicago Bears – Kenny Britt WR Rutgers
    Kenny Britt is a good looking prospect at 6’4 with great speed he has been climbing up draft boards. He should give Chicago a legitimate weapon to play opposite Devin Hester.

    19. Tampa Bay Buccaneers – Mark Sanchez QB USC
    This could be an ideal situation for Mark Sanchez who has great tools, but I feel will struggle if played too early. It seems that Luke McCown has worked his way to starting QB for 2009, but I don’t think anyone expects him to be the future of the franchise.

    20. Detroit Lions –Aaron Maybin OLB Penn State
    I expect Detroit to pick up a MLB in the free agency, and Ernie Sims is a great linebacker and this pick should finish the job. I think Detroit can address cornerback late in the draft and Max Unger should still be available come pick 33.

    21. Philadelphia Eagles – Brandon Pettigrew TE Oklahoma State
    Pettigrew is a great tight end prospect that can both block and catch. Pettigrew will help support an aging offensive line and fills a need with the departure of LJ Smith.

    22. Minnesota Vikings – Vontae Davis CB Illinois
    With Minnesota trading for Sage Rosenfils I don’t think Minnesota will take a huge gamble on Josh Freeman. Minnesota needs help in the aging defensive backfield and Vontae Davis can provide it.

    23. New England Patriots – Clay Mathews LB USC
    Clay Mathews is a solid football player from a great family. He can play any position the Patriots ask of him and he fits the profile of a Patriots linebacker.

    24. Atlanta Falcons – D.J. Moore CB Vanderbilt
    D.J. Moore was absolutely amazing as both a cornerback and a kick returner and the Falcons need help at both. They would love Brandon Pettigrew here.

    25. Miami Dolphins - James Laurinaitis ILB Ohio State
    James Laurinatitis isn’t the sexiest prospect in the draft, but the guy is a football player and I could see Parcells falling in love with him.

    26. Baltimore Ravens - Alphonso Smith CB Wake Forrest
    Baltimore’s weakness in their D was the long passing game and Alphonso Smith is a good step towards repairing that. The guy doesn’t have the best measurable but no CB has performed better in college.

    27. Indianapolis Colts – WR Jeremy Maclin
    Harrison is gone and the Colts have the ability to simply reload. Harvin could provide lethal speed and should add an exciting new spark to Peyton’s offense. The Colts have a real need at DT, but I don’t think any prospect warrants this pick.

    28. Philadelphia Eagles - Michael Oher OT Mississippi
    Some once had Michael Oher as the top tackle in the draft, he has now fallen to the late first round. Philadelphia’s offensive tackles both have more than 10 years of experience and its time to build towards the future.

    29. New York Giants - Brian Robiskie WR Ohio State
    Brian Robiskie gave one of the most impressive combine performances and has pushed his way into the first round. This is New York’s number one need, even if Plaxico escapes jail time.

    30. Tennessee Titans – Jarron Gilbert DT San Jose State
    Jarron Gilbert has become a youtube sensation and is a physical freak. His measurables are ridiculous for a defensive tackle and he could be asked to fill Albert Haynesworth’s rather large shoes.

    31. Arizona Cardinals – Donald Brown RB Connecticut
    Donald Brown had a better combine performance than either of the two RB’s I have in front of him and he should provide a good alternative to Tim Hightower.

    32. Pittsburgh Steelers – William Beatty OT Conneticut
    Marvel Smith has yet to be signed and William Beatty is the best tackle available.

    Round 2.

    1. Detroit Lions – Max Unger C Oregon
    Max Unger could be the best offensive line prospect for the Lions in this draft. He can play center, guard or right tackle and he will start day one.

    2. St. Louis Rams - Eben Britton OT Arizona
    Many expect St. Louis to pick a tackle in the first round, so its obvious the need is there. Eben Britton has risen since the end of the season.

    3. Kansas City Chiefs - Paul Kruger DE Utah
    That Kansas City defense needs a lot of help and Paul Kruger could provide a great spark.

    4. Cleveland Browns - Coye Francies CB San Jose State
    Coye Francies came from a small school but has seen his stock risen thanks to a fantastic Senior Bowl practice.

    5. Seattle Seahawks – Peria Jerry DT Mississippi
    Seattle needs help on both lines, but there isn’t a tackle here worth the pick.

    6. Cincinnati Bengals – C Alex Mack
    Alex Mack coupled with Jason Smith is a great way to build a long lasting offensive line.

    7. Jacksonville Jaguars – Percy Harvin WR Florida
    Jacksonville has been trying to find a legit receiving threat for a long time, if Harvin falls to him here they could finally fix that problem.

    8. Oakland Raiders – Sean Smith CB Utah
    Sean Smith is a very interesting CB prospect at 6’4.

    9. Green Bay Packers -- Darius Butler CB Connecticut
    Their defensive backfield is aging.

    10. Buffalo Bills – Jared Cook TE South Carolina
    Jared Cook is a physical freak and could be a real sexy receiving option for Trent Edwards.

    11. San Francisco 49ers – Josh Freeman QB Kansas State
    Josh Freeman is arguably a first round talent, San Francisco can’t rely on Shaun Hill or Alex Smith being the QB of the future.

    12. Miami Dolphins – Louis Delmas S Western Michigan
    Thanks to William Moore’s poor performance at the Senior Bowl Louis Delmas becomes the top prospect.

    13. New York Giants -- Rey Maualuga OLB USC
    He had a poor combine and some question his speed so he may fall out of the first round.

    14. Houston Texans -- Michael Johnson DE Georgia Tech
    Michael Johnson is a statistical beast with all the talent in the world, but was an inconsistent performer. If Mario Williams can help him fulfill his potential he could provide a scary alternative.

    15. New England Patriots -- Rashad Johnson S Alabama
    Rodney Harrison is on the NFL Network.

    16. Denver Broncos -- Marcus Freeman LB Ohio State
    Denver needs linebackers and Marcus Freeman has high upside.

    17. Chicago Bears -- Andy Levitre OG Oregon State
    The best guard in the draft in a weak year for the position.

    18. Tampa Bay Buccaneers -- Connor Barwin DE Cincinnati
    Kevin Carter is getting old and they need to look for a replacement.

    19. Dallas Cowboys William Moore S Missouri
    Was once the top safety in the draft, but he should be able to replace Roy Williams.

    20. Philadelphia Eagles LeSean McCoy RB Pittsburgh
    Philadelphia needs a between the tackles runner, LeSean McCoy could be that back.

    21. New York Jets –Jairus Byrd CB Oregon
    The Jet’s secondary is pathetic and they need help at the position.

    22. Minnesota Vikings -- Jamon Meredith OT South Carolina
    Jamon Meredith has all the physical tools but got benched in college. He has huge potential but has bust written all over him.

    23. Atlanta Falcons -- Shawn Nelson TE Southern Mississippi
    I was more impressed with Nelson than any other receiver at the combine.

    24. Miami Dolphins --Hakeem Nicks WR North Carolina
    Miami needs an offensive weapon and Hakeem Nicks is a steal here.

    25. Baltimore Ravens -- Cornelius Ingram TE Florida
    Ingram was hurt last year but looked solid at the combine. Baltimore needs to make up for Todd Heap’s slowing in production.

    26. New England Patriots – Herman Johnson OG/OT LSU
    A huge prospect that can play either guard or tackle.

    27. Carolina Panthers -- Nate Davis QB Carolina
    The NFC Championship game made it obvious Carolina needs to prepare for a day without Jake Delhomme.

    28. New York Giants Evander Hood DT Missouri
    Evander Hood was one of the strongest defensive lineman in the draft.

    29. Indianapolis Colts – Ron Bryce DT Boston College
    He played behind Raji, but he is a talented player that the Colts desperately need.

    30. Tennessee Titans – Pat White QB West Virginia
    Pat White looked great the combine and offers a lot of possibility in Tennessee. The Titans need another receiver, help at punt return and with Vince Young being Vince Young he may have a shot at playing Quarterback.

    31. Arizona Cardinals -- Duke Robinson OG Oklahoma
    This would be a high value pick here.

    32. Pittsburgh Steelers -- Jonathan Luigs C Louisville
    An athletic center prospect that can help keep Big Ben upright.

  8. #8
    Motor City Sonics's Avatar
    Motor City Sonics is offline MotownSports Fan
    Join Date
    Oct 2002
    Location
    Dearborn Heights
    Posts
    19,814

    Default

    I hope you're wrong.....they need to take ALL DEFENSE in the first 3 rounds....5 guys that can step in and play from day 1.
    AAT: VICTOR MARTINEZ

    SOMEONE TELL ME WHAT A CLEAN BLOCK IS? BECAUSE THE NCAA SURE DOESN'T KNOW!

  9. #9
    Stormin' Norman's Avatar
    Stormin' Norman is online now MotownSports Fan
    Join Date
    Jan 2009
    Location
    Orlando, FL
    Posts
    1,390

    Default

    I disagree.

    I think the Lions can find two starting CB's in the late rounds, I would target Asher Allen and Joe Burnett in the third and fourth. I think the Lions can sign a MLB in the free agency draft a another outside backer and then build your offense. With tools like Calvin Johnson and Kevin Smith I think you have to build around that - adding a franchise QB and building the Oline is key.

  10. #10
    GuitarGod19's Avatar
    GuitarGod19 is offline MotownSports Fan
    Join Date
    Jan 2006
    Location
    Grand Rapids, MI
    Posts
    2,029

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Hongbit View Post
    I give you an A for the effort. A full 2 round mock with analysis is a hard thing to do even if I disagree with many of your selections.

    I honestly would throw a rock at my TV if the Lions took a Center at the top of the 2nd round with so many quality playmakers still on the board. Taking Unger over Maclin, Jerry, Nicks, and yes even Maualuga would be reaching for need rather taking the best available player. Eric Wood, Antoine Caldwell, and AQ Shipley are available later and round out a center class with nice depth.
    Unger is more than a center, he started his first two years at tackle then moved to center, he can also play guard. His versitility is a great thing to have, he's a jack-of-all-trades, but a master of none. He's riding a good combine right now and his stock is high.
    Never underestimate the power of the Schwartz

    2010 AAL - Sammie Lee Hill 15 Tackles 1.5 Sacks

  11. #11
    GuitarGod19's Avatar
    GuitarGod19 is offline MotownSports Fan
    Join Date
    Jan 2006
    Location
    Grand Rapids, MI
    Posts
    2,029

    Default

    I disagree with a lot of those picks...but I'll stay with the picks you have for the lions. Stafford is a good pick, worthy of the #1 and no argument from me.

    I however can't see us taking an OLB that is virtually the same size and make-up of a guy we all ready have on our roster (Avril) when there are so many bigger needs. SSLB is probably the least important player on the D and we are 2 CBs away from having 2 starting NFL caliber corners. With Davis, Moore, and Smith on your board still, one of them should be the choice.

    Unger is a solid prospect, but if you have Maualuga still on the board and we don't take him at 2-1 that's crazy...even if we did sign a MLB in free agency like you suggested, he could still kick outside. Plus we have a need at DT and Jerry, Hood, or Brace would be a solid choice.
    Never underestimate the power of the Schwartz

    2010 AAL - Sammie Lee Hill 15 Tackles 1.5 Sacks

  12. #12
    DetroitFan's Avatar
    DetroitFan is offline MotownSports Fan
    Join Date
    Jun 2007
    Location
    Hawaii
    Posts
    2,474
    Blog Entries
    1

    Default

    I can't see the niners passing over Mark Sanchez for English. I also can't see Maualuga and Mack both dropping down that far.

    Maualuga has good enough film and potential to negate his subpar combine- which may have been due to injury.

    If Maclin and Harvin drop that far the Lions almost HAVE to consider taking one of them at 20. Good thing it probly won't happen.

    I doubt Chris Wells goes before Moreno.

    I will be disappointed if Orakpo goes that high but it maybe could happen after the combine that he had.

    I can't see that many LBs being taken in the first.

    Donald Brown over LeSean McCoy? Really?

    I can't see Michael Johnson dropping that far. If there's one thing NFL scouts love, its potential.


    Well those are the more major things I noticed.
    Last edited by DetroitFan; 02-23-2009 at 11:58 PM.

  13. #13
    wingnut736's Avatar
    wingnut736 is offline MotownSports Fan
    Join Date
    Jan 2004
    Location
    Multiple Locations
    Posts
    2,840

    Default

    Main problems I have with the first round:

    Cushing, Heyward-Bey, English, Ayers, and Gilbert are all way too high IMO.
    09-10 AAW: Dan Cleary
    2010 AAT: Cody Satterwhite

  14. #14
    syrett4's Avatar
    syrett4 is offline MotownSports Fan
    Join Date
    Apr 2002
    Location
    Lafayette Park
    Posts
    1,956

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Stormin' Norman View Post
    I disagree.

    I think the Lions can find two starting CB's in the late rounds, I would target Asher Allen and Joe Burnett in the third and fourth. I think the Lions can sign a MLB in the free agency draft a another outside backer and then build your offense. With tools like Calvin Johnson and Kevin Smith I think you have to build around that - adding a franchise QB and building the Oline is key.
    I just keep seeing 21-0. That isn't the fault of the offense. How many games were they down by 21 at some point in the game...7 maybe? First 5...4 D and 1 OL.
    But you aren't a man. Men are not supposed to like Streisand movies. Its just not right. - Estrepe1 VT

  15. #15
    BigBoiKzoo is offline MotownSports Fan
    Join Date
    Feb 2009
    Location
    Kalamazoo
    Posts
    617

    Default

    Cushing isn't a ILB. He isn't even projected as such from what I've seen. I don't agree with most the picks, but honestly trying to do a mock is something I'd never care to try as there is just too much that I don't know about many of the teams.

  16. #16
    cruzer1's Avatar
    cruzer1 is offline MotownSports Fan
    Join Date
    Apr 2002
    Location
    Here
    Posts
    31,470
    Blog Entries
    7

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by BigBoiKzoo View Post
    Cushing isn't a ILB. He isn't even projected as such from what I've seen. I don't agree with most the picks, but honestly trying to do a mock is something I'd never care to try as there is just too much that I don't know about many of the teams.
    He could play it just like AJ Hawk or Aaron Curry could. He would be fine there. He's a natural will, but can play any position.
    Last edited by cruzer1; 02-24-2009 at 08:21 AM.
    Where's Zimm?
    Adopt-a-Tiger: Danry Vasquez
    Adopt-a-Lion: Willie Young
    VT

  17. #17
    BigBoiKzoo is offline MotownSports Fan
    Join Date
    Feb 2009
    Location
    Kalamazoo
    Posts
    617

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by cruzer1 View Post
    He could play it just like AJ Hawk or Aaron Curry could. He would be fine there. He's a natural will, but the Lions already have Sims.
    Hawk is the OLB for the Packers. I just checked NFL.com to verify that. I just hadn't heard anything about Cushing moving to ILB. That is why I stated that. I've heard about Curry moving.

    I like Cushing the most out of the USC linebackers so I'm not going to say anything bad. Heck, when I saw some of the first mocks that had us getting him with our second round pick, I was elated.

  18. #18
    cruzer1's Avatar
    cruzer1 is offline MotownSports Fan
    Join Date
    Apr 2002
    Location
    Here
    Posts
    31,470
    Blog Entries
    7

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by BigBoiKzoo View Post
    Hawk is the OLB for the Packers. I just checked NFL.com to verify that. I just hadn't heard anything about Cushing moving to ILB. That is why I stated that. I've heard about Curry moving.

    I like Cushing the most out of the USC linebackers so I'm not going to say anything bad. Heck, when I saw some of the first mocks that had us getting him with our second round pick, I was elated.
    They're moving him inside, to the mike.

    http://www.greenbaypressgazette.com/.../90222025/1058
    Last edited by cruzer1; 02-24-2009 at 08:28 AM.
    Where's Zimm?
    Adopt-a-Tiger: Danry Vasquez
    Adopt-a-Lion: Willie Young
    VT

  19. #19
    TigerPride8301 is offline MotownSports Fan
    Join Date
    Apr 2007
    Location
    Lansing
    Posts
    872

    Default

    Just my 2 cents which isn't worth much, but I want the Lions to take Jason Smith or Curry with the first pick. I know taking Curry is a slight overdraft but I think he is a beast and will help the defense drastically.
    2012 AAT: OF Avisail Garcia '11 Lakeland stats: .264 avg, .297 obp, .389 slg, .686 ops
    2011 AAL: 5'9 RB Jerome Harrison #36

  20. #20
    cruzer1's Avatar
    cruzer1 is offline MotownSports Fan
    Join Date
    Apr 2002
    Location
    Here
    Posts
    31,470
    Blog Entries
    7

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by TigerPride8301 View Post
    Just my 2 cents which isn't worth much, but I want the Lions to take Jason Smith or Curry with the first pick. I know taking Curry is a slight overdraft but I think he is a beast and will help the defense drastically.
    The Lions are in great shape at QB. Why would they want a young stud? There's no need. They need better LB'ers and linemen.
    Where's Zimm?
    Adopt-a-Tiger: Danry Vasquez
    Adopt-a-Lion: Willie Young
    VT

  21. #21
    BigBoiKzoo is offline MotownSports Fan
    Join Date
    Feb 2009
    Location
    Kalamazoo
    Posts
    617

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by cruzer1 View Post
    The Lions are in great shape at QB. Why would they want a young stud? There's no need. They need better LB'ers and linemen.
    This is where the love'em or hate'em comes in. Is he worth the risk or not? He has a lot of upside, but with our team needs so much, is he worth the risk? We are in as bad of shape (if not worse) at LB than at QB. At least we have a one time guy who had 3 very good years and he now has similar offensive tools that he had in Minnesota. Simms is an OK LB, but nothing to write home about. Other than that, we have zip. To me there is far less risk of Eugene Monroe, Aaron Curry, or Jason Smith busting than Stafford. The millions we give them would be safer and would go further to making us a solid team for years to come.

    When we're closer to having a complete team, we can get that QB we need. With a good team around them, even rookie QB's can do well as they've proven in recent years (Ryan, Flacco, Roethlisberger). That is my feelings on it. He's just not worth the risk when we need so much. If he ends up being an elite QB with someone else, oops, we missed. There is no saying he would have been that with out team.

  22. #22
    cruzer1's Avatar
    cruzer1 is offline MotownSports Fan
    Join Date
    Apr 2002
    Location
    Here
    Posts
    31,470
    Blog Entries
    7

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by BigBoiKzoo View Post
    This is where the love'em or hate'em comes in. Is he worth the risk or not? He has a lot of upside, but with our team needs so much, is he worth the risk? We are in as bad of shape (if not worse) at LB than at QB. At least we have a one time guy who had 3 very good years and he now has similar offensive tools that he had in Minnesota. Simms is an OK LB, but nothing to write home about. Other than that, we have zip. To me there is far less risk of Eugene Monroe, Aaron Curry, or Jason Smith busting than Stafford. The millions we give them would be safer and would go further to making us a solid team for years to come.

    When we're closer to having a complete team, we can get that QB we need. With a good team around them, even rookie QB's can do well as they've proven in recent years (Ryan, Flacco, Roethlisberger). That is my feelings on it. He's just not worth the risk when we need so much. If he ends up being an elite QB with someone else, oops, we missed. There is no saying he would have been that with out team.
    He's not much of a risk to me. It would be riskier to not take him. He's that good.

    Ask Minnesota how easy it is to find a QB when they have the rest of their team put together well. They'll never get over the hump without a QB.

    The Lions won't fix everything in this draft, but they can make a huge dent.
    Where's Zimm?
    Adopt-a-Tiger: Danry Vasquez
    Adopt-a-Lion: Willie Young
    VT

  23. #23
    nd1377 is offline MotownSports Fan
    Join Date
    Nov 2005
    Posts
    1,917

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by BigBoiKzoo View Post
    When we're closer to having a complete team, we can get that QB we need. With a good team around them, even rookie QB's can do well as they've proven in recent years (Ryan, Flacco, Roethlisberger). That is my feelings on it. He's just not worth the risk when we need so much. If he ends up being an elite QB with someone else, oops, we missed. There is no saying he would have been that with out team.
    Would a "complete team" draft in the top 5 if they were a "complete team"? When QBs were drafted first overall or in the top 5 in the past, were the teams that drafted them "complete teams"?

  24. #24
    sagnam's Avatar
    sagnam is offline MotownSports Fan
    Join Date
    May 2007
    Location
    White Lake, MI
    Posts
    11,147

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by cruzer1 View Post
    Ask Minnesota how easy it is to find a QB when they have the rest of their team put together well. They'll never get over the hump without a QB.
    And the Lions will never get to the hump without a defense and line.
    AAL: Matthew Stafford | AAW: Nicklas Lidström | AAT: Jesus Ustariz
    ah yes, the danger of a precedent that MLB will get important calls correct, we certainly want to avoid that at all costs. - pyrotigers
    All it takes is a half-hour each day to look after your groin, and we got a professional group. - Mike Babcock

  25. #25
    BigBoiKzoo is offline MotownSports Fan
    Join Date
    Feb 2009
    Location
    Kalamazoo
    Posts
    617

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by nd1377 View Post
    Would a "complete team" draft in the top 5 if they were a "complete team"? When QBs were drafted first overall or in the top 5 in the past, were the teams that drafted them "complete teams"?
    Did I mention anywhere that we're a complete team or teams in the past have been that draft in the top 5? Very few teams in history, if ever, have had such a complete lack of talent as the Lions have. I think the expansion year Bucs are about the only team that is there with us on lack of talent. We need someone at every position. I do mean every.

    Why does a QB have to be taken in the first part of the draft to be considered a franchise QB? Experts miss all the time. People who subscribe to arm strength not being the end all be all and accuracy being the most important factor can see that. Arm strength and lack of experience are why Brady was drafted so low. Brady completed 63% of his passes and had a 4:1 TD/INT ratio. He also won the big games. You can find gems later in the draft, you just need to not always subscribe to the flashy pick.

  26. #26
    cruzer1's Avatar
    cruzer1 is offline MotownSports Fan
    Join Date
    Apr 2002
    Location
    Here
    Posts
    31,470
    Blog Entries
    7

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by sagnam View Post
    And the Lions will never get to the hump without a defense and line.
    Those are easier to gather.
    Where's Zimm?
    Adopt-a-Tiger: Danry Vasquez
    Adopt-a-Lion: Willie Young
    VT

  27. #27
    sagnam's Avatar
    sagnam is offline MotownSports Fan
    Join Date
    May 2007
    Location
    White Lake, MI
    Posts
    11,147

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by cruzer1 View Post
    Those are easier to gather.
    Apparently not.
    AAL: Matthew Stafford | AAW: Nicklas Lidström | AAT: Jesus Ustariz
    ah yes, the danger of a precedent that MLB will get important calls correct, we certainly want to avoid that at all costs. - pyrotigers
    All it takes is a half-hour each day to look after your groin, and we got a professional group. - Mike Babcock

  28. #28
    syrett4's Avatar
    syrett4 is offline MotownSports Fan
    Join Date
    Apr 2002
    Location
    Lafayette Park
    Posts
    1,956

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by sagnam View Post
    Apparently not.
    At least not for the Lions.
    But you aren't a man. Men are not supposed to like Streisand movies. Its just not right. - Estrepe1 VT

  29. #29
    lesgoblu02's Avatar
    lesgoblu02 is offline MotownSports Fan
    Join Date
    Feb 2004
    Location
    San Antonio, TX
    Posts
    22,366
    Blog Entries
    1

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by sagnam View Post
    Apparently not.
    When you are talking about every other NFL team, they absolutely are. When discussing the Millen era Lions, they absolutely are not. But that doesn't make cruzer's statement less true. We just had a GM who threw darts at a dartboard when evaluating talent.
    Every time you play a hand of you poker you wanna run through a mental check list. Head Position Hand Position Neck Position Breathing Posture. More than 25 items. It's a lot. And that why I've come up with a handy mnemonic device. Just one word: HPHPNPBPECMSPAMDCPAFTSTTL. It's easy.

  30. #30
    nd1377 is offline MotownSports Fan
    Join Date
    Nov 2005
    Posts
    1,917

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by BigBoiKzoo View Post
    Did I mention anywhere that we're a complete team or teams in the past have been that draft in the top 5? Very few teams in history, if ever, have had such a complete lack of talent as the Lions have. I think the expansion year Bucs are about the only team that is there with us on lack of talent. We need someone at every position. I do mean every.
    What is wrong with taking a QB first and then using your other picks and free agency to build your team into something closer to a complete team? Based on probability a QB chosen higher has a better chance of succeeding compared to a later round QB. I know you will have anomalies, but the Lions have two first round picks so this year is a good year to take a chance on what could be a franchise QB.
    Last edited by nd1377; 02-24-2009 at 01:20 PM.

  31. #31
    DetroitFan's Avatar
    DetroitFan is offline MotownSports Fan
    Join Date
    Jun 2007
    Location
    Hawaii
    Posts
    2,474
    Blog Entries
    1

    Default

    Here's what I posted in another thread that you decided not to reply to...

    Cruzer, if this was 15 years ago, I'd agree with you.But the game has evolved- its not about how well you can throw the ball.

    In fact that's only a very small part of it.

    Its about quick release; quick, good decisions; audibles; reading defenses; mantal toughness; leadership; and grit.

    If it was up to who had the best arm, the top 5 QBs would probably be

    Jamarcus Russell
    Kyle Boller
    Joe Flacco
    Tarvaris Jackson
    Jay Cutler

    The game has evolved. Its made it tougher to evaluate talent at the QB position.

    Yes, he has the physical tools, but that's only about 40% of it IMO.

    Most of the better qbs don't have exceptional arms, and most of the ones that do don't rely on arm strength to win.

  32. #32
    djhutch's Avatar
    djhutch is offline MotownSports Fan
    Join Date
    Oct 2002
    Location
    Midland, MI
    Posts
    22,082
    Blog Entries
    4

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by DetroitFan View Post
    Here's what I posted in another thread that you decided not to reply to...

    Cruzer, if this was 15 years ago, I'd agree with you.But the game has evolved- its not about how well you can throw the ball.

    In fact that's only a very small part of it.

    Its about quick release; quick, good decisions; audibles; reading defenses; mantal toughness; leadership; and grit.

    If it was up to who had the best arm, the top 5 QBs would probably be

    Jamarcus Russell
    Kyle Boller
    Joe Flacco
    Tarvaris Jackson
    Jay Cutler

    The game has evolved. Its made it tougher to evaluate talent at the QB position.

    Yes, he has the physical tools, but that's only about 40% of it IMO.

    Most of the better qbs don't have exceptional arms, and most of the ones that do don't rely on arm strength to win.
    From what I've heard of Stafford, he's as good at the chalkboard as he is throwing the ball a mile.
    2013 AAT: Dan Dickerson All-Time AAT: Charlie Maxwell
    If a woman has to choose between catching a fly ball & saving an infant’s life, she'll choose to save the infant without even considering if there are men on base. ~ Dave Barry

  33. #33
    BigBoiKzoo is offline MotownSports Fan
    Join Date
    Feb 2009
    Location
    Kalamazoo
    Posts
    617

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by nd1377 View Post
    What is wrong with taking a QB first and then using your other picks and free agency to build your team into something closer to a complete team? Based on probability a QB chosen higher has a better chance of succeeding compared to a later round QB. I know you will have anomalies, but the Lions have two first round picks so this year is a good year to take a chance on what could be a franchise QB.
    Again, that goes back to my previous post where you have to go by risk reward? Is it worth the overall #1 pick to risk on a QB that has at least a 50/50 chance of being a bust whereas you can draft an OT or LB who has less of a chance of being a bust? It almost goes without saying that Curry has almost no chance of being a bust. Very few linebackers in quite awhile have put up his numbers and had his measurables. The move from college LB to pro LB isn't as hard as college QB to pro QB. Spend the #20 pick or a pick another year on a QB. To me with so many holes, I just cannot see spending so much money on a risk AND for a guy that most likely would have to sit his first year and eat up $8+ million to hold a clipboard. To me, being a finance guy, that makes no sense whatsoever.

    I also don't think there is any real correlation to a higher draft pick translating into a better QB. For every 1st round starter, I've guessing there are 3-4 back ups and benchwarmers.

  34. #34
    BigBoiKzoo is offline MotownSports Fan
    Join Date
    Feb 2009
    Location
    Kalamazoo
    Posts
    617

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by djhutch View Post
    From what I've heard of Stafford, he's as good at the chalkboard as he is throwing the ball a mile.
    See, this is the part I don't like about Stafford and it makes me really scared about him as a pro.

    I've heard he goes through his progressions well. He's good at knowing the plays (chalkboard). He has a cannon for an arm. If he is so smart, why does he throw the ball so hard over the middle on crossing routes? Why does he consistently throw into double coverage? Why does so many of his throws involving the WR having the jump to catch the ball? All of those traits to me translate into INT's in the pros.

    Until he learns to not try make the big play and let the play evolve on its own, I think he's just going to be a guy that will always throw about as many INT's as TD's in the pros like a QB we're about to cut, Kitna.

  35. #35
    nd1377 is offline MotownSports Fan
    Join Date
    Nov 2005
    Posts
    1,917

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by BigBoiKzoo View Post
    Again, that goes back to my previous post where you have to go by risk reward? Is it worth the overall #1 pick to risk on a QB that has at least a 50/50 chance of being a bust whereas you can draft an OT or LB who has less of a chance of being a bust?
    How do you figure 50% chance? When you factor in a players better skills and abilities compared to others, doesn't the chance go above 50% that he will be a success? How do you figure an OT or LB having less of a chance of being a bust? You can look at any year and point out successes and busts at any position.

  36. #36
    Fool Inc.'s Avatar
    Fool Inc. is offline MotownSports Fan
    Join Date
    Jun 2004
    Posts
    1,904

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by nd1377 View Post
    How do you figure 50% chance? When you factor in a players better skills and abilities compared to others, doesn't the chance go above 50% that he will be a success? How do you figure an OT or LB having less of a chance of being a bust? You can look at any year and point out successes and busts at any position.
    QB is without a doubt the riskiest pick. There is only one quarterback on the field and two more that are strictly backups. If you bust as a QB, it's a total waste for a team. If you bust as a LT, there is a chance of moving to RT or OG. The same goes for the other positions you would draft with the number one pick. Hell, most of the positions have multiple spots to. Say you draft a WR and he's a slight bust. There is a good chance he's still good enough to be a #2 or slot reciever and you can still get something out of him. There isn't anything you can do with a backup quarterback than help the starter and train up the 3rd stringer.
    2011 Adopt-A-Tiger: P Brad Thomas
    2011 Adopt-A-Lion: WR Nate Burleson

  37. #37
    Gozer is offline MotownSports Fan
    Join Date
    Feb 2009
    Location
    OC
    Posts
    230

    Default

    I know its steep but what about offering up to get Cassel. Give up #20 and next years first round. Then we don't have to risk picking up Stafford this year and we can draft Curry and still get a great addition with pick #33. And we wouldn't have to risk drafting an unknown next year on a QB. Cassel is 27 or 28 with a lot of mileage left and proved he could get it done. No risk and get what we truly need...a franchise QB. Not sure if the price is to steep but still worth an argument.

  38. #38
    BigBoiKzoo is offline MotownSports Fan
    Join Date
    Feb 2009
    Location
    Kalamazoo
    Posts
    617

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by nd1377 View Post
    How do you figure 50% chance? When you factor in a players better skills and abilities compared to others, doesn't the chance go above 50% that he will be a success? How do you figure an OT or LB having less of a chance of being a bust? You can look at any year and point out successes and busts at any position.
    Giving Stafford a 50/50 chance of not being a bust was favorable IMO. Look at underclassman QB's. Almost all of them fail in the NFL. Look at David Greene. Who is he? He's just the QB that was there at Georgia before Stafford and put up better numbers than him with less talented skill players around him. No, I no hard numbers to back any of this up, but look a history and underclassmen who are drafted who throw under 60% completion percentage in college and have throw as few of balls as him also. His TD/INT ratio also sucks over his college. The odds aren't in his favor. You have a statistician put it together and I'd feel comfortable that a 50/50 chance of being a bust is being nice.

    As far as offensive tackles, Smith and Monroe have almost no question marks. They've been considered solid picks and Smith's stock has only gone up recently even more. A 1st round pick from last year couldn't beat Monroe out for his LT position.

    For LB, you'd have to be completely stupid to think that moving from college MLB to pro MLB isn't easier than college QB to pro QB. I hate QB's as much as the next defensive minded person, but QB is the most complicated/high pressure position in football.

    Curry has a skill set and physical tools that not a lot of linebackers have. The only thing Stafford has that not a lot of other QB's have is his arm. If arm strength was the most important tool in a QB, I would be more on Stafford's side.

  39. #39
    BigBoiKzoo is offline MotownSports Fan
    Join Date
    Feb 2009
    Location
    Kalamazoo
    Posts
    617

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Gozer View Post
    I know its steep but what about offering up to get Cassel. Give up #20 and next years first round. Then we don't have to risk picking up Stafford this year and we can draft Curry and still get a great addition with pick #33. And we wouldn't have to risk drafting an unknown next year on a QB. Cassel is 27 or 28 with a lot of mileage left and proved he could get it done. No risk and get what we truly need...a franchise QB. Not sure if the price is to steep but still worth an argument.
    We don't have to give up two firsts for him since he signed the tender with the Pats. It's up to the Pats now what they get for him, if they even want to trade him. Try could trade him for a 7th round pick if they'd like. The team that gets him would have to pay the $14MM 1 year contract unless they redid the contract (which they most likely would).

  40. #40
    BigBoiKzoo is offline MotownSports Fan
    Join Date
    Feb 2009
    Location
    Kalamazoo
    Posts
    617

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by BigBoiKzoo View Post
    Look at David Greene. Who is he? He's just the QB that was there at Georgia before Stafford and put up comparable numbers to him with less talented skill players around him. No, I have no hard numbers to back any of this up, but look a history and underclassmen who are drafted who throw under 60% completion percentage in college and have throw as few of balls as him also.
    Since the site isn't letting me edit. This is what it should have said.

Page 1 of 3 123 LastLast

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •